日本財団 図書館


LAOS COUNTRY REPORTMOH
I. OVERALL GOALS AND OBJECTIVES OF PROJECT
A. Goals of Revolving Drug Funds
 
Main goals To improve health services (curative and preventive) by using medication from RDFs as a means of entry for reaching community health needs
  To contribute to the reduction of children's under-five mortality and morbidity due to low accessibility to health care services
Specific goals To improve accessibility to essential drugs
  To improve health care accessibility for poor people
  To increase community participation and involvement
Parallel goals To monitor and rationalize essential drug use
B. Overall Goals of National RDF Project
 
Specific objectives To train people on RDFs at central, provincial, and district levels and at RDF sites
  To assist in implementing and monitoring RDFs with implementing partner
  To supervise and evaluate the running of RDFs
  To have a unit at the MOH gathering information and collecting data, as well as serve as a communication point with implementing partners
Parallel objectives    
  At public facilities To improve the drug management system
  To set up an accounting system
  To introduce controllable self-management in public facilities
  To set up standardized monitoring, control, evaluation, and reporting
  At the community level To provide interested villages with management tools for running RDFs
  To provide an easy, reliable replenishment system linked with supervision
  To limit the list of items to administrated by the VHW
II. SPECIFIC OBJECTIVES FOR THE CURRENT REPORTING PERIOD (11/96-10-97)
National RDF program
 
1. To distribute RDF guidelines (first version) to the field
2. To review RDF guidelines (second version) for hospitals, health centers, and communities
3. To develop guidelines on supervision, evaluation, reporting and training on RDFs
4. To develop guidelines on the role of provincial and district pharmacies in RDF systems
5. To prepare training program on RDFs
6. To train teams of RDF trainers at central and provincial levels and at RDF sites
7. To train provincial hospitals on RDFs
8. To assist to the implementation and monitor RDF with implementing partner
9. To supervise and evaluate the running of existing RDFs
10. To set up a unit at the MOH to gather information, collect data, and serve as a communication point with implementing partners
11. To set-up a database on RDF in Lao PDR
12. To answer the needs of assistance from provinces and implementing partners
13. To review the National RDF Program
III. ACHIEVEMENTS AGAINST EACH OBJECTIVE FOR THE CURRENT REPORTING PERIOD
National RDF Program
1. To distribute RDF guidelines (1st version) in the field
・ Distributed guidelines to provinces, provincial hospitals and implementing partners
 
2. To review RDF guidelines (second version) for hospitals, health centers, and communities
 
・ National RDF guidelines for hospitals reviewed by RDF Committee
・ Held working session in Louang Prabang (training center) on review of guidelines
・ Made corrections of national RDF guidelines for hospitals and health centers
 
3. To develop guidelines on supervision, evaluation, reporting and training on RDFs
・ Drafted national guidelines for RDF Committee (on supervision, evaluation, training)
 
4. To develop guidelines on the role of provincial and district pharmacies in RDF systems
・ Draft of guidelines on the role of provincial/district pharmacy in RDFs
 
5. To prepare training programs on RDFs
 
・ Commenced planning of training activities
・ Started writing training modules
 
6. To train teams of RDF trainers at central and provincial levels and at RDF sites
・ Not yet performed
 
7. To train provincial hospitals on RDFs
・ Not yet performed in RDF program, but completed in programs of implementing partners (Savannakhet)
 
8. To assist implementing partners in implementing and monitoring RDF
・ Not yet performed in RDF program but completed in programs of implementing partners (UNICEF, Sante sud)
 
9. To supervise and evaluate the running of existing RDFs
・ Not yet performed in RDF program but completed in programs of implementing partners (SRC, UNICEF)
 
10. To set up a unit at the MOH to gather information, collect data, and serve as a communication point with implementing partners
・ Setting up of a secretariat and practical organization of the program
 
11. To set up an RDF database in Lao PDR
・ Started database of RDF statistics for monitoring and evaluation
 
12. To respond to calls for assistance from provinces and implementing partners
 
・ Preliminary training in Bokeo (five districts)
・ Evaluation of RDFs and cost recovery system in Paksan Provincial Hospital
 
13. To review the National RDF Program
 
・ Now redefining National RDF Program (objectives, planning, tasks, resources)
・ Redefining overall budget and proposal following Nippon Fundation visit
IV. GENERAL STATUS OF RDF PROJECT
A. Performance of RDFs
 
1. Number of RDFs established
 
・ RDF established in 51% of public health facilities
・ RDF established in 7% of villages
NUMBER OF RDFS
  No. RDF
facilities
Total no.
facilities
% RDF
facilities
Central hospitals 2 7 29
Provincial hospitals 17 18 94
District hospitals 84 84 63
Health centers 271 271 47
 
2. Functioning of RDFs
 
 Today, it is still difficult to estimate how well RDFs are operating in terms of efficacy and quality:
 
・ Big differences between RDFs
・ Some RDFs are like private pharmacies while others concentrate on improvement in quality of care
・ RDFs with fixed objectives, training sessions, and guidelines usually do better

No.RDF facilities 807
TOTAL no. facilities 11.640
% RDF facilities 7
 
3. Why a number of RDFs are not functioning
 
・ Lack of training
・ Lack of supervision and evaluation
・ Lack of objectives
 
4. Community involvement
 
Community RDFs Contract or agreement with the village for implementation of RDF
  VHWs chosen by agreement with village leader
  Management of RDF controlled by village leader
RDFs in public health facilities One or more persons of each community are members of the community RDF committee
 
5. Performance of replenishment system
 
PERFORMANCE OF REPLENISHMENT SYSTEM
  Types Performance
I. Replenishment through "the public health channel," province to district Difficult to implement for the moment without assistance because of lack of training in drug management, in drug procurement, in RDF systems, etc.; risk of delays and stock-outs.
II. Replenishment system organized by health facility with control from provincial pharmacy and agreements with suppliers Possible to implement with a bit of training and collaboration between health facilities and provincial pharmacy
III. Non-organized replenishment system by the public health facility Easiest system to implement but prices usually high because of small orders with small suppliers; risk of interference by personal interests and lack of quality control
 
6. Supervision by MOH and NGOs
 
Supervision by MOH Still on spot basis
  Mainly MOH people are hired by IOs and NGOs to perform supervision and evaluation
  Included in the RDF program, which is good start in responding to implementing partners and provinces
  Supervision guidelines exist for each level
Supervision by NGOs Organized regular, indicator-based supervision by some NGOs
  Supervision performed as part of global assistance activities in situ
 
7. Financial reports
 
・ Reporting principles included in national guidelines
- Monthly report of the management committee with financial data's on RDF
- Supervision every three months
 
・ In practice
- Monthly reports are not yet ofter sent to upper level but remain in public health facilities
- Annual reports summarize RDF financial performances
 
8. Pricing of drugs
 
・ Pricing principles are included in the national guidelines. Prices are maximum 125% of purchasing price (allowing 10% for inflation, 10% for RDF administrative costs and 5% for transport)
・ Principles are, in practice, followed by the majority of RDFs
B. National Drug Policy
 
1. Review of national drug policy and Essential Drugs List
・ Essential Drugs List for Lao PDR reviewed on 7 April 1997 (1218/FDD): 261 items
 
2. Changes in laws, guidelines and procedures for the financial management of the drug supply
・ Selection of direct delivery system (centralization of needs, contracts with suppliers, decentralization of orders, based on local manufacture) for the national procurement of drugs assisted by SIDA
 
3. Changes or reviews of guidelines for logistic management
 
4. New projects aiming to improve NDP and links with RDFs
 
・ Assistance from WHO/STC from March to September 1997 for start of RDF program
・ Drug supply assistance from SIDA for 1998 to 1999 period
 
5. Changes in policies, guidelines and procedures for cost recovery
 
・ Agreement on the General Policy on Cost Recovery & RDFs reached on 30 September 1997
・ Second version of National Guidelines on RDFs for hospitals, health centers
C. Strengthening Management Capabilities of District and Provincial Health Services
 
1. Programs in strengthening management capacity teams and links with RDF project
 
・ Writing of guidelines on supervision, reporting and evaluation for RDFs (WHO/STC)
・ National RDF program should start from training of central trainers, to provincial RDF committees, to provincial hospitals, and so on
・ NGO and IO (e.g. SRC, MSF, EED, UNICEF) assistance programs "in situ"
 
2. Efforts to integrate RDF supervision into overall supervision
 
・ Not yet performed on an official basis
・ On experimental basis with NGOs working through in situ training
D. National Health Budget
 
1. Percentage of national budget for health and changes since 1996
・ 1995-96 7.5% (source: Report of IV National Conference on Health, 08/97)
 
2. Percentage of national budget allocation for PHCs and for drugs and medical supplies (1995-1996)
 
・ 1.633% of national budget allocation for the purchase of drugs (+/- 3$/pers/h), which is 12.23% of health budget
・ 0.212% of national budget allocation for medical equipment, which is 1.59% of health budget
 
3. Change of MOH budget since implementation of RDFs
 
・ Of course it is increasing because all the provided drugs are for sale
・ Exemption is very limited
 
4. Increase or decrease of government funds supporting successful RDFs
・ The Lao government yearly provides funds for purchasing drugs to each province according to its population7 size; provided drugs are included in RDF system
V. PROBLEMS ENCOUNTERED
A. Key Problems during Period
 
・ Uncertainty regarding possible financing of National RDF Program
・ MOH-led changes in RDFs
・ Incentives for VHWs in community RDFs
・ Rising inflation
・ Lack of training and supervision
B. Main Reasons
 
・ Unclear position of Nippon Foundation and unclear request from MOH
・ Ongoing structural review at MOH
・ Community RDFs generate little income
C. Longstanding Problems
 
・ Uncertainty regarding need to pay 20% reimbursement to treasury
・ No clear official position for the payment of civil servants who pay for drugs through insurance (they pay themselves then ask for reimbursement, or hospitals pay first and are then reimbursed by MSW)
・ No clear official position on who should pay, who not and who should decide it
D. External Circumstances that Contributed to Problems
・ Ongoing structural review at MOH
VI. ACTIONS TAKEN TO RESOLVE PROBLEMS
A. Actions Taken
 
・ WHO budget for local costs in six month periods
・ Engaged WHO for six month short-term consultation on RDFs
・ Decided to review National RDF Committee and attach it to FDD Department
B. Results of Actions
 
・ Draft of guidelines on supervision, reporting, training on RDFs
・ Second version of RDF guidelines for hospitals and RDFs
・ Review of National RDF Program
C. Positive and Negative Factors in Resolving Problems
 
・ Decision making around RDFs should be easier because RDFs have been attached to one department
・ National Health Conference has urged the MOH to take practical approach regarding the implementation of Decree 52/PM on treatment payment (e.g. who should be exempted, treasury reimbursement, civil servants)
D. Support Provided by UNICEF, The Nippon Foundation, University of Tokyo
 
・ Two visits from the Nippon Foundation resulting in one positive assessment from a consultant
・ Extension of community RDF program from LWU/UNICEF in the field
VII. FUTURE PLANS
A. Objectives or Activities Scheduled for Next Reporthing Period
 
See National RDF Planning
 
1. To train theams of trainers at national, provincial and district levels on revolving drugs fund guidelines and training methods
2. To train all staff people in working posts related to the revolving drug fund management system and VHWs
3. To train staff at provincial and district pharmacies in order to enable RDFs to run successfully in provinces and communities
4. To implement, monitor and evaluate revolving drug funds in targeted areas according to the General Policy on Cost Recovery and RDFs and to the National Guidelines on RDFs
5. To have a unit at the MOH gather information, collect data, and serve as a communication point with implementing partners
B. Resources Required:
 
  Financial resources:   US$663,513 for one year
  Technical assistance:   might be needed (not included in the budget)
C. Time Frame:
 
  One year
D. Indicators for Measuring Achievement of Objectives
 
 See Guidelines for Evaluation of RDFs
 
What was measured   Indicators used
Sustainabilithy of RDF Increase of RDF value since start of RDF
  Use of state drug donations for the poor
Management of RDF Percentage of prescriptions delivered
  Quality of operations per post in comparison to jobdescription
Equity of RDF Attendance trends (OPD, IPD, total)
  Percentage of free treatments for poor people
  Percentage value of treatments for the poor people in total value
  Trend of patient professions
  Trend in origins of patients (<3km, 3 to 10km, >10km)
Quality of care Trend in accessibility of drugs
  Indications of good management practices
  Percentage of essential drugs on the list
  Trend in quality of prescriptions for three sample diseases
E. Monitoring and Evaluation of Achievements
 
・ Monthly management committee and report
・ Supervision by upper level every three months for public health facilities, on the spot for villages
・ Evaluation of public health facilities every six months
F. Support Required from UNICEF and MOH/NGOs
 
・ Continue LWU/UNICEF project in community RDFs
・ NGOs acting as implementing partners: follow the General Policy on RDFs and main principles of RDFs; use guidelines as a base for implementing RDFs: assist RDF committees in training, supervision, evaluation; take care of financial costs related to RDFs in areas where RDFs are working; and propose technical improvements
・ UNICEF working as a ゛super" NGO in public health facilities with RDFs in collaboration with RDF committees
・ Nine central trainers responsible for training, supervision, evaluation
・ Decision making on RDF policy and main principles
G. Technical Assistance Required from Donors and Costs Involved
 
・ Technical assistance to RDF committees could be needed for at least the first year of program
・ Costs involved depend on financing agency rates








日本財団図書館は、日本財団が運営しています。

  • 日本財団 THE NIPPON FOUNDATION